Which broadhead are you shooting this upcoming season or which broadhead have you been shooting? I'm going to try the Magnus black hornet this year.
I have a quantity of 3 different BH's that I use as the mood strikes......Shuttle-T, Magnus Stingers/Buzzkuts, and NAP Hellrazors. Each of them can be hand sharpened and resharpened, plus they fly true and have repeatedly proven to put game on the ground. The past year and a half I have shot Shuttle-T's almost exclusively and they have done a very commendable job. The only mechanicals I shoot are Slick Trick Nukes for turkey hunting.....not big game.
I've been shooting Thunderheads since 2004. Bought a Diamond bow last April and couldn't tune them at all. Bought a pack of Rage and was able to get a bit closer but never got withing shooting range of a deer last season. Bought an HTR in March and the Thunderheads tuned perfectly with my FPs without playing with them at all. I really don't know how the Rages would've performed, but I know THs do. My buddy bought a pack of THs to try and went with another fixed. He knew someone wanting Rages so I gave him my Rages for his THs and he traded the Rages to another guy for the kind he likes. LOL!
Wac'em. Also tried a Phathead and DRT. All three fly well. I think any good broadhead will fly well if the bow is tuned. Wac'em is my go to broadhead.
Exodus the last three years. Switching to a cut on contact this year but have not narrowed it down to which one yet.
I shoot bloodrunner II. Complete pass through with big bloodtrail Only 7 yrd shot lol. fly right with my field points.
Rage 125 grain hypodermic on the end of a CX Piledriver total weight 475 grains, bone does not concern me.
NAP 100 grain Thunderhead....simple and deadly I love them. They've been around forever and still are one of the top broadheads on the market