I'd say my does average 130. My last 4 bucks have been 175, 200, 190, 185 dressed weight. They were all at least 3.5. BTW, I use a scale so no guesstimating. I think people would be surprised when their 200 lb deer tips the scales at 150. Not saying that about anyone here though.
Up in Maine 2 years ago I was absolutely shocked. I saw the tracks and others actually saw the deer several times. It was a doe that would have dressed 180+ easily. No one had a doe tag though.
i definitely know what your talking about ive seen big bodied does up in maine and couldnt believe they werent bucks being of that size!!!