That a buck has returned from the previous year? Me and my brothers have spent HOURS going through trail camera pictures this year looking for similarities between last years and this years bucks. Its enjoyable no doubt (18,000 pictures is alot), but for the life of us...we can only find one, MAYBE 2 bucks that have returned. We had a number of unique deer last year on cam that we were excited about seeing again, that simply disappeared. Understandably, a few probably got shot, and a few died from other reasons. But in our close knit community, we usually here about all the bucks that get harvested (Especially anything noteworthy). Were running 11 cameras total right now, and have always had at least 5 in the woods from January. Back to my original question, how do YOU individually identify your bucks year to year? I know alot of you have history with certain animals, and id like to see pictures of the changes they go through and how you continue to identify them. Is it possible for deer to continue to add G-points once they are mature? Things of that nature... I will post a few of (what i think are) my own examples when i can tonight. Forgive me if i have posted this before, but it is something i find very interesting about deer and deer hunting.
I like to look for body characteristics.......split ear. a scar. any pattern to color on face or throat patch
Really just depends on the deer. I have a few the bone alone gives them away no questions asked. Others I use other distinguishing features.
^^^^^^^^this^^^^^^^^^ I've seen deer add and lose G's from year to year. In fact JZ sometime back posted one of his multi-year bucks and he lost some mass and a unique curve to one tine and maybe lost another tine I can't recall for sure but he changed enough to make questionable. I look for as many unique features as possible...sometimes there aren't any to speak of.
Yup. I might see one feature from one year to the next, but that doesn't guarantee to me that its the same deer.
Antler characteristics. I know of 4 bucks in 6 years of running cams that I was able to 100% identify from one year to the next. Most bucks here don't live to 2.5 years old otherwise my numbers would be higher. Also remember what Lady forge said- in high deer population areas 70 to 80% of 1.5 year olds relocate the next year as 2.5 year olds. So that alone would make it tough to keep track of a buck. Sent from my XT907 using Tapatalk
I only have two that I can confirm... that was from '07-'08. Pics came from the same exact tree also... I have several other pics of each... but these are the ones I have quick access to on photobucket. This is the same deer as above... but focus on the deer to the right... he came back with him in '08 also... '08 He's on the back right of this pic also AND he also came back in 2009... only to NEVER be seen by my own eyes... I never knew the demise of any of these deer...
The first two pics is Hard2Handle, the buck I shot this year. The first pic is one that I got of him last year. He showed up for two sets of pictures at the end of October and apparently never left, as I had bunches of pictures of him this year. You can see (hopefully) that last year as a 2 1/2 he had dual split brows. This year, he only began the nub of one of the splits. The next three are of Zeus, in three consecutive years starting in 2010. He was a straight mainframe 8, turned into that gnarly thing in '11 and then mellowed out a little in '12. Three pretty different racks each year. He lost splits on a G2, gained an extra point, got smaller splits on the brows (but more bladed). Obviously, he had a very unique frame along with big brows that gave him away, but otherwise he changed quite a bit each year. On deer without excess of character, I think beam length/curvature/form is probably the most distinguishing way to tell bucks apart year to year.
I don't even bother looking at 1.5 year olds for that reason. I start with 2.5 yo bucks. I always seem to have mature deer show up for one year, then they vanish and are replaced by different mature bucks. Or they just look alot different.
My property here at the house is exactly the same way. Tracking the same buck from one year to the next here is a very rare thing. We'll see what happens next year on my management land though. We have a lot of deer and a lot of old coal mined land with pits and dumps. I think these bucks just take a notion to travel where the does are and hit food sources along the way and then return to their basic core home range and the next year (if they survived) they may venture another direction chasing does or food or just a notion.
I don't get enough damn bucks on camera to follow them. My two from last year are still MIA. A property I hunted in the past i had a couple I followed for a year or two, basically based on antler characteristics. I do have a few does that I've followed, one my son named "funky face" because she has what looks like her nose was bitten by a yote or something, and a second one looks like she was shot at...long streak down her side.
I have the same problems Caleb. I'll have a buck on camera all summer and all fall and winter, and find his shed or sheds, and then he never shows back up. 2 years ago it was this buck: And then last year it was this buck: I don't think it was too much hunting pressure because I feel that they would not have stayed local throughout the entire season. They wintered there as well because I found their sheds... But then they never showed up at all the next season. I cant explain why... Thoughts?
I use the same things already mentioned, such as the antlers and identifiable markings. I also pay close attention to the times and dates from year to year. There have been some times that bucks show up that don't stay there the rest of the time and they show up within a couple days of the year prior. This doesn't necessarily make it the same deer, but using it as a starting point I may be able to pick up a small characteristic by tracing it back to pictures from previous year(s). I've been able to do this on more than one occassion. It's not foolproof, just another way to try and keep track of these suckers.
Takes time as it has only happened a few times for me but you look for some marks or distinct antlers or something and you can just tell.
This is exactly the kind of reply I was looking for. I don't know how to explain it. Hunting pressure could be the issue. Maybe he got bumped from his "preferred" bed one to many times and relocated. Maybe his core range shrunk as he got wiser/older? Somebody may have killed or poached him and kept it quiet too. That 199" that my brother shot totally switched his core area from one year to the next. The summer of 2008 he was captured on the same trail camera at a mineral lick hundreds of times. I found his shed so we knew he survived the season, but he never came back to that mineral lick ever again. When my brother killed him the next fall, we heard from another hunter that he was on trail camera all summer in a totally different area. Which proved that he changed his home range as a mature buck. There are so many different things that could cause this...but since it was summer it had to be food or bedding? Right?
I know I've probably posted it before, but I have some interesting maps at home (I'm at work now) that I downloaded off QDMA showing different bucks that were fitted with tracking collars. It's interesting how they moved throughout the year. It's actually quite fascinating. Some would have different home ranges for different seasons and would travel between the two on the same exact trail only twice a year. Alot of the bucks didn't have your typical "oval" shaped home range like you would expect, and alot of the time it depended on terrain and crop rotation.
I seem to see different mature bucks year to year. Maybe not 5 and half year old every year, but nicer deer. I always wondered why I couldn't see the same bucks. Several factors in my situation come into play. Hunting pressure. Lots of smaller bucks are shot so we don't always get a chance to see them grow and get to know them. What I think is the biggest part or at least a big part is how much land you are covering with cameras. I'm only putting out a couple cameras because we mainly only hunt two really good fingers that are on our land. Only having two cameras could be affecting this by only having a small sample of deer. On another note I know several people that recognize the same deer year after year. I think the biggest difference is they have more land to take their sample of bucks and they have restrictions on the size of deer that are shot that make it easier to recognize the nicer deer year to year. Not sure if that is correct, but that is what I have come to believe. Doesn't mean I don't look for marks on deer, but it is easier to find the same deer the more cameras and land you have covered. Sent from my SCH-R530U using Tapatalk