Depends on the time of year. I only have one tag for the whole season, so if its before the end of october, no. But any later then that, and I am flinging an arrow at him.
I have two big ones on the wall with my first ever buck "5 Pointer" is also on my wall. I really like the buck and will probably pass due to other big ones out there. Just thought I would ask since that is a really big 4 pointer.
I say let him walk if you have other good shooter deer on the property. This guy is young, and while he isn't great development wise at this stage, in many parts of the country it has been a tough year on deer due to drought and things of that nature. Now if next year he remains week and isn't adding brow tines or points...cull buck!