Same Deer?

any guesses on age and score? also not 100% sure these are not the same deer. Thoughts?

 

Same deer. 120's I'm thinking.

 

I don't think so. Both nice bucks though.

Blessings.........Pastorjim

 

I'd say it's the same deer. Great looking buck.

 

Looks to me like the one that has the earlier date is not in velvet. I would say no.

 

Welcome to the site!

I think they are different. The velvet buck's right side G3 has a pretty distinct crook in it's tip that is missing on the hard antlered buck. Might just be the angle, but to me, the velvet buck looks longer in tine length too.

 

I say same deer ! 3.5 year old.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 4

 

Same deer. The right brow tine is unmistakeable. I thought the same thing as Fitz at first but I think that its the angle. The crook is pointing towards the camera so it "disappears". The little extra G4 on the left antler is also a dead giveaway. Nice looking deer that is likely 120's.

 

Same buck. Probably mid 120s. Good luck!

 

Same low 120's

 

hard to tell but they do look similar i would saw low 130's to high 120's

 

I think its the same

 

yup same deer

 

I'm thinking they're the same buck. It sure looks like the velvet picture has a taller G3 on his left side than the other (I realize this could be because of his velvet) but the brows look identical. I think its more likely that the taller looking G3 appears that way because of the different perspectives and velvet than the chance that two bucks have the identical looking brows..