I can vouch for the frogs. Jason tipped me off to them last summer. It was later in the season when I finally tried them, and they did pretty well. What was also nice for me was a lot of times the real small ones would hit it, but not get hooked, but the big boys were fine getting hooked up.
I have never used the Mans.... I fish the Sizmic pop'n toads though.... Link for the Pop'n toads. http://www.unclejosh.com/sizmiclure/modules/cart/products.php/nav_id/54/page/1/id/102/name/NEWSizmicPopNToadFLOATING