Off season hunting

Ok... Look at the picture, you have 3 buck tags and unbelievably the 3 bucks in the picture all walk into the opening at the same time. What order would you shoot them in? Which one 1st? 2nd? and last? and why?

 

# I love the character

#2 he is a brute

#3 is no slouch either but ranks 3rd out of these 3 for me

 

#2 because of his mass
#1 because of character
#3 i love his height but I like mass and character more

 

#2 cause he is just a brute and has age.
#3 he looks older then #1.
#1 cause you said we had 3 tags and we could shoot him. Would really like to see him the falling year when he masses up. I would be perfectly thrilled to kill just 2 out of the 3.

Tim

 

2,3,1. 2 is wide and huge, 3 is nice and tall, 1 is a little tighter rack but still a great buck.

 

#2 - he's huge
#1 - like others said, awesome character
#3 - because one of them has to be shot last

 

2
3
1

Just my opinion.

 

This is my order as well. How many points on #1?

 

2, 3, 1

#1 looks young still. I like #2's mass and #3 is cool because I like tall tined 8 pointers.

 

Same here!

 

2
3
1
2.Because I love big 8pts and he is a brute and looks older than number 3, Then number 3 because again i love big 8pts. Then number 1 who is nop slouch but again i love big 8pts..

 

score wise highest to lowest would be:
#1 ( 180's NT 15 Point )
#2 ( 160's typ. 9 point )
#3 ( 140's typ. 8 point )

Age wise my best guess would be
#1- 5 y/o
#2- 6 y/o
#3- 4 y/o

Anybody wanna change there mind?

My picks are biased, but would be:

#2
#1
#3

 

I would shoot #1 first simply because I would love to shoot a non-typical. I really like the width of the #2 but the height of #3 is pretty impressive. I guess 2 would be second because he's got a neck like a horse.

 

I figured #1 would score better then both but in " this " picture of just the 3 bucks... he looks younger and I figured him at 3.5 . After seeing your other post of all the bucks... I knew I made a mistake and then figured him at 4.5 and #3 at 4.5 .

I still like #2 the best.
#3 or #1 second ( who ever gave me the first shot )

Tim

 

2
3
1

I have a 5 pointer "My First Ever Buck", 10 pointer, and 11 pointer on the wall and for some reason I have a very large drive to kill a MONSTER 8 pointer. I really want one bad. For some reason all my 8 pointers are very young ones and boy they are lucky because of that. I have a big 10 pointer gene pool at my spot. I wish one would stay an 8 point.

 

#1- character and all those points. I can't kill anything but 8pts.

#2- mass and width. I can't kill anything but 8pts.

#3- no slouch but he's an 8pt and I can't kill anything but 8pts.

 

Definately #2 first! Love the width and mass.

#1 next because of the character and abnormal points

#3 last, no slouch like others have stated. Definately wouldn't let him pass though if he came walking by.

 

2,3,1
that was my 1st thoughts and still after reading the update I would shoot them in that order.

 

I like big 4x4s.. initially I thought he might be my 1st choice, the NT I can't see very good at that angle, picture doesnt do him justice imo, the big dude in the middle, yeah he's just a slob. All great bucks, chit I'd shoot any of them, who ever offered up the best shot first, then the next, and the final one.. any order.. if I had 3 tags and could shoot 3 in one day! imagine that hero picture! LMAO

 

If I was going on rack alone I would probably go (looks not necessarily the score)
3 because his rack is just about picture perfect, long brows, long G2 and everything is just how you picture its supposed to be
1 because of character
2 last because he has the ugliest rack of the 3

If I was going off age
2 6.5
3 5.5
1 4.5