Ive used both and they are both a solid broadhead,Its just all about shot placement. But i will say i had issues with the 4 blade flying a little corkscrew like.
good broadhead. shot deer and bear with the mx-3. fly good, but am going back to the slicktrick standards this season. awesome head and seems just a little sharper than the mx-3, plus flys great also. but the mx-3 is a good broadhead.
I personally shoot Grim reapers, but if I had to shoot fixed blades... Slick Tricks or Muzzy's would be my ONLY 2 choices.. Something about a broadhead that has been proven time and time again for being a very reliable, tough, easy to replace blade broadhead !!!! There is a reason they are still on the shelves after this long, and not pulled and closed down company..
I have been using the Muzzy 3 blade since they started making them. They do the job and have never failed me. Well over a hundred kills with them. Many of the heads have been used for multiple kills.
And... the blades can be resharpened unless they are damaged. I shoot three and four bladed and both are durable, accurate heads with a near zero chance of blade loss.
Ill be doing the same except im using the magnum 125grs. I like them better than the muzzys I was using last year. The Slicktricks are built so much stronger and you dont have the threads on the front to break(which I did, I broke 3 before the season even started) so STs it is for me this year. Im excited to see the "slug holes" they produce.
I use muzzies and I have no complaints. When it comes to things that simply must work every time, its best to keep it simple.
Muzzys fly like sh** for me and I paper tuned my bow to perfection and they still swirl, just a junk head so i shoot a slick trick magnum
I just took my first deer ever and used the original muzzy 3 blade 100 grains. The blades are trashed, but they are cheap to replace. And as stated previously, I bought a 6 pack on eBay for the same as a 3 pack of any other broadhead. Mine flew exactly where I was aiming and was a clean shot straight through. Entrance and exit wounds looked like someone cut a triangle piece of skin off the sides. He made it about 20 yards before collapsing. I have to say that they do the trick.
I've shot a dozen or more deer with Muzzy's over the years and never had a problem. I am going back to the standard 3 blade Muzzy's this year and expect the same results. I have been using Magnum 2 blade broadheads the past couple of years. I like them but they are extremely difficult to sharpen.
I'm gonna be shooting muzzy mx-3 this season and hopefully I have the opportunity to harvest my first whitetail with a bow.. I get to start this Sat the 15th. Super excited! Good luck everyone Nock em down, Drag em out!!
Every Deer I've hit with a Muzzy 3 or 4 blade are dead. Idk what other proof you need. I also say that it doesn't really matter what you shoot these days, if you have a great shot with a fine tuned bow you won't have a problem. I think it's never the Bhs fault, it's the shooter.
