If you're talking about the buck that was chronicled for 8.5 years, then yes. I can't really tell (pic quality) on the one Scott posted. How far "down" can a buck go in antler size once he gets really old? I've heard so many people say they can become a spike again but I have a hard time believing that.
No.. I was talking about my 1.5 yr old to 2.5 yr old from my mock scrape. Trying to un-effectively point out the radical but otherwise similiar qualities the photgrapher has with his buck as compared to mine. Between those ages. Which you questioned (for good reason) last week I think?? Nevermind though... it was a lazy attempt to bust your chops.
The episode I watched can be had + the entire season for less than $10 TYD if your really interested in getting it. Double check, but I believe it was season four based on the description.... "Join noted whitetail expert Charlie Alsheimer for over 5 hours of original programming including a buck's life, progression of treestand safety, deer movement insight, rut predictions, food plot discussions, QDM burnout and more!" http://www.krausebooks.com/product/deer-deer-hunting-tv-season-four-dvd/outdoors_hunting
He stayed within an 8 inch span from 4.5 to 10.5. Very Intresting. If that was the norm, i bet there is alot of bucks being mis-aged out there.