Yes I have it and have mixed feelings. If I want to do some light rattling when they're close this works perfect but when I want to get into it and make some noise with the thing, to me, it doesn't sound at all like the real thing. How you grip the thing makes a big difference on the sound made which I also dont like. I got it as a gift so Im not going to complain too much, just another thing to add to my arsenal.
I have one, compared to my old Primos rattel bag, it sounds better with more volume and easier to use with gloved hands.
I have it and it does work but sounds like 2 smaller bucks.......the new magnum one sounds like 2 mature bucks. Get one of each and sound like a group of bucks taking turns!!
I use one, and overall I like it. Could sound more realistic when your really giving it hell, but it does the job for me