I want your opinions on this buck. What would you do?

I agree he's a older. If it was me I'd take him.

 

He looks to be 4.5 years. I'd take him out.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Given everything you've said...I'd probably kill him...

Given hunting pressure on land we do not own & hunt...and hunting pressure on surrounding land...very few of us have hundreds of acres that we own and can manage to the point of letting a solid 3-4 year old deer pass...in hopes..of him showing up next season.n

That being said...only kill a deer you want to kill...easier said than done...if someone else walks him...you can feel good about at least giving him a chance...but given my thoughts on his age...he is not going to bloom into a monster...my 2 cents...

 

I believe he is a 3 year old deer! thats a good deer buddy. For where your at if thats a good deer and thats what makes you happy by all means shoot it, i will say i think that deer could become a monster.....its up to you, but dont regret shooting a deer of this size.

 

Personal choice 100% never should another's opinion control a harvest unless it is someone else's ground with minimums.



The above is because I personally cannot stand that mindset. Shoot what will make ya happy and roll with it!

 

It is hard to give an answer with out knowing a few things. Have you killed deer bigger than this buck and what do you consider a giant?

 

What part of north Mississippi?

 

If there's bigger on the property pass if not take him

 

I would say 4, nice deer, I would shoot him.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

I'm guessing 3. There are lots of valid points here. Do what YOU want.
Since you asked, not a shooter in "my" eyes.