Odd ball rack for sure, antlerless doe seems to fit but could be a number of things. That's terrible, wrong in my opinion.
I know right.....bleh. It happens naturally too sometimes though, fences, yotes, birth defects...etc.
Awesome character deer, I love it! Antlerless doe seems to fit for sure, they usually don't shed the velvet from their antlers, but I also have never seen or heard of an antlerless doe to grow that big of a rack. Cool for sure!
I hunt in Buckingham (right next to Goochland) . I have heard of that club before. That is a crazy looking deer. I say deer because I think its a doe also. My mentor in bow hunting killed an antlered doe years ago in Cumberland county but it was a perfect 8 pointer and had shed the velvet. He has it on his wall.