About 5 feet behind the paper and that's what I thought because I'm never getting the same tear I'm thinking my form is inconsistent
I think the first two photos and the last are consistent enough, try moving your rest up a smidge. Then possibly a little to the right. You want to have your paper far enough from the target to ensure your arrow is horizontal in flight, and position yourself 5-7 feet behind paper. Might not be your form, but could be peeking to make sure your arrow hits the target behind the paper.