Antlered doe or buck?

I can't figure out if this is an antlered doe or a buck that may have been neutered. What do you all think?

 

Name = porcupine !

Looks old to me but hard to tell if it's a buck or doe. I say buck. I want to see him get all that velvet rubbed off !

 

Looks like a doe or a Blue buck. I would love to shoot one!

 

Skinny, sickly looking thing. I'd say buck and I'd also say something bad happened to that thing for that rack to grow all goofy like that.

 

I have to agree with this. Body does look large but very emaciated. It would be nice if you get some more photos now after the velvet has come off.

Blessings........Pastorjim

 

Whatever it is, that thing looks like its on its way out. I would shoot that out of pitty.

 

I agree with Buck, looks like a roman nose and old.... I would also say he prob has testical damage and prob wont shed his velvet!

 

Shoot it and let us know!

 

That looks like a senior citizen cool looking rack odd deer all around

 

I have a couple pics of this deer from last year. They were taken in mid October. Still had the velvet then. The deer definitely looked healthier then as well. The body on this deer is huge compared to other does so I am starting to lean toward buck as well. Every one of us in our lease group is out to tag this deer out of curiosity and as it seems it may not last another year.

 

Do you guys have a Hutners Feeding the Hungry trype program in your state?

I would, for sure, be donating that meat....

 

It is most likely a doe or damaged buck,The does with antlers that I have seen have been somwhat like this one but the points were longer.I would shoot him and try and save the velvet on the antlers