1st! I think it makes the deer look bigger and the white shade helps the deer stand out. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
What? the second shows the fletchings better, and is an old metal coated ceramic like an old outdoor light from back in the day, all the light is reflected to the antlers.
On a serious note, I would find a nice Tiffany Shade slightly larger then the second picture. Something to make it less morbid.
Then what a about a section of roth iron, you can have it nicely twisted and antiqued?....maybe some arrow shaped design . Then a Tiffany shade over it