Just look into a known company such as primos or something. They all have a different sound and will be personal preference
I used the Buck Roar from Primos this season and I was truly impressed. I haven't tried any other ones so I cant speak for other brands.
I like my Flextone buck collector, but I also hear great things about the Primos Buck Roar, do some research and like the post above me said, its mainly personal prefernce.
I use a Primos Buck Roar, had great luck using them. Me and a buddy were hunting on my main ground, and we called in 8 bucks in one afternoon hunt with it. They ranged anywhere from a little spike to a 140" 10. Needless to say I am going to keep using it for years to come.
Also used the promos buck roar, grunted any several deer with it, one from over 100yds away across a creek. Also like to use the primos can call at times.
I have both the primos buck roar, and the buck collector..... buck roar is great call, but you can make a roar sound and so much more tone changes with your calling with the buck collector. I called in and killed my 136" twn point this last season. I will own this call for a VERY long time Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Primos Buck Roar. I've called in all types of deer with it. Does and bucks. My 2012 buck came in to a roar that I gave him from 100 yards out at a full run to fight. I shot him at 20 yards.
I use the flextone bone collector call. I love the sound of it, but i have never called a deer in with it.
I have 16 calls in a box.....only this one in my pocket. http://www.illusionsystems.com/shop/extinguisher-deer-call/ The most realistic I have heard and easy to use. Also made in USA.
And the sad truth Cole is that the 140" was perfectly safe the whole time where you hunt! *did I ever tell ya how jealous I am