Looks at least 4. I would need to see more body pictures. My score guess is upper 150's. The one side is a lot weaker than the other.They don't look as nice out of velvet. I wouldn't pass
As big as his body is in that first pic for this time of year, I'm thinking 4.5 - 5.5... I'd cull him out of the herd just because of his genetics.
I think you should post the pictures and not pictures of the pictures, it would be more clear and easier to see, but that's just me being anal. I would not consider that borderline, in my neck of the woods that is a shooter without question. Maybe you should name it "Border Patrol" since you think it's on the border of being a shooter lol.
I'd take him. 140ish 3.5 but not older than 4.5 Remember they always look huge in velvet. Experts say it adds like 20%
His name is "Lefty"...he told me telepathically For me I have shot several 100-130" bucks, but nothing bigger...so he gets shot When I have shot several 130-150" bucks I'll let a buck like this walk so I can increase my odds of shooting a 150+ deer